Originally Posted by AAAA
If it couldn't be plugged, then it probably was a large hole. Get a new tire. You have so few miles you probably just need to replace one and not all 4.
The repair was done by Americas Tire, aka Discount Tire.
I would have gone there first, as they will patch any repairable tire free.
America/Discount Tire is usually pretty good at telling you whether or not a repair is a good idea vs a new tire--suppose there are some stores that aren't but it really isn't in their best interest to do so.
What put the hole in the tire, and is it near the edge of the tire?
A nail/screw puncture, no big deal if repaired by a tech with a pulse.
Rock gash, glass cut, etc. where you can see damage on the tread at all, I'd be very inclined to consider the worth of the vehicle and my body vs a tire.