You'll get three different answers.
Husky Weather Beaters (which is what I have)
Jeep Slush mats
They'll all serve their purpose. The Huskys don't have a big red logo. (the Weathertechs do), the Jeep ones have a big Jeep logo. I like the Husky Weatherbeaters since 1. they don't have a logo, 2. the rear mats cover the entire area including the middle hump between the seats. 3. It provides the ability to cut out the area of the cargo mat by the subwoofer if you want. Also, it completely covers the front area (no holes for the hooks) The Jeep slush mats (in my opinion) shouldn't have the holes. Just looking at mine, I know I'd have stained the carpets underneath already. (which isn't that big of a deal... after all... this IS a Jeep)
The Weather Beaters in action: