FWIW, I replaced the handles on my '12 and paid about $400 for the set of handles and about $150 for the install. Much more than I wanted to spend, but didn't know of another option to rid myself of the chrome handles, and was concerned about the durability of paint when you're grabbing them daily. Was determined to do the install myself, but ran into issues when I got the door panel off, so decided to take it my trusted body shop instead.
I did have my mirror caps painted over a year ago and they still look great, and you'd never know they weren't stock.
Didn't know the handles could be vinyl wrapped, and might have considered it if the price was right and I trusted the work. First time I saw wrapped handles was on Duc's Jeep, and it looks pretty damn nice. Last page of his build thread has a picture. May want to reach out to him if interested...
Stone White GC Overland w/ some mods