Originally Posted by pjp91389
I'm trying to come up with the best way to replace it. I know it's going to have to be painted to match the rest of the body, but the dealer wants over $100 to paint it, on top of the $75 for the part itself.
The paint cost is in the ballpark of what any shop might want to paint it. The part you might find $10 or so cheaper, but you'll probably have shipping. Check any of the online Mopar sites
The Overlands have the same flares as the Limited/Laredo except non-textured and painted, right?
Since it's black, I'd do what darknit3 suggests. Heck, even the Duplicolor black would probably work.
The plastic rivets on the fender flares are one-time use, unless you have the push rivets. So, you'd need a rivet gun and the right replacement rivets. There's a kit on ebay for about $25.