NO!!!! Don't do it! Get Daniel our Vendor to paint your tails! He's the best! And for the headlights I will show you a picture of mine and I bet you'll like them. BTW Is your Jeep a Limited or Laredo? And What Color is it?
I agree with Paul, Daniel is excellent for tinting lights and even painting items for that matter. If you can afford some downtime without your tails or headlights, I would go that route (I actually did).