Re: JK Soft Top Recomendations
Full disclosure, I only have experience with Bestop and more specifically the Trextop NX. I don't know the difference between the material used in the NX verses the Sailcloth Replace A Top either, if there's any. That said, we installed the NX in Aug. At the end of Oct, my wife and son were involved in a 60 mph head-on accident (they're both ok, the Jeep did her job and protected the occupants) where the Jeep was flipped up on her top. NOT A SINGLE TEAR. Granted, this was on a dirt embankment/shoulder, not a lot of concrete or rock, but there was evidence of the top digging into the dirt a bit. I'm pretty sure that there's a good chance the fabric itself could be reused.
TL;DR - The Trextop NX fabric is tough stuff, I would guess other Bestop materials would be equally as tough.