Jeep Garage  - Jeep Forum

Jeep Garage - Jeep Forum (http://www.jeepgarage.org/forums.php)
-   Troubleshooting/Problems (http://www.jeepgarage.org/f181/)
-   -   another one stalling (http://www.jeepgarage.org/f181/another-one-stalling-65479.html)

vipper303 09-14-2013 08:57 PM

another one stalling
 
well guys, this one of the few times I have posted to a forum. I am in need of some help with my 07 commander limited w/ 5.7 hemi. It has taken a notion to die at random times while driving down the road. I had hoped it was bad gas by the way it was reacting after just recently puting a few gallons in less than a half mile before the first stall episode. So far I have tried gas-dry and fresh gas, a new map sonsor, cleaning the throttle body, new champion 570 spark plugs (the correct factory type plug), the condition seems slightly better, but, this evening while driving it, the stalling is not as bad, it seems to just die, resart, and continue running, all with out any input from me. it is not throwing any codes other than a p0884, which is an intermittent signal loss to the tcm. I believe that code is irrelevent and caused by the engine dying while driving down the road, and all the research i have done states that replacing the pcm/tcm unit did not help. I am asking if there is a likely chance that throttle body assembly is going bad, or is there some else that has proved to be the answer to this situation. I am having a hard time finding consistant information and recent answers on various sites in regards to this. I would like thank all that respond in advance for your time and help.

dr.lee.baugh 09-14-2013 09:47 PM

Re: another one stalling
 
Welcome to the forum.

Mileage? Maintenance history?

Have you ever replaced the EGR valve? Is it stalling at slow speeds, fast speeds, or at any speed?

vipper303 09-14-2013 10:07 PM

Re: another one stalling
 
thanks for replying, this is a new to me vehichle, it had 110k when I got it, it now has 125k, the history is unknown to me. It went for six plus months on irriduim plugs with no problems (in when purchased, I have changed the plugs only this one time). It will die anytime anywhere. The only thing that I have seen is the light for the etc pop up as it restarts on its own (only while driving, doesnt resart when in park/neutral). i have read many post in regards to the egr valve, how does that cause the engine to die randomly? I only ask so that I can better understand this engine. And again thanks for you time.

dr.lee.baugh 09-15-2013 12:13 PM

Re: another one stalling
 
The EGR valve opens up to allow exhaust gas to go back into the engine to lower the combustion chamber temperature (yes it sounds weird that exhaust gas would lower combustion temperatures...but it does!).

This helps improve fuel efficiency, reduces emissions, and allows the engine to run cooler, as the combustion point of the fuel is lower. Basically, it allows the engine to run much leaner, without causing knock.

If the EGR valve is stuck, the computer can not adjust the correct amount of exhaust gas coming back into the engine, and this can cause it to stall (most often at idle or low RPMs when the EGR valve should be closed).

It does not sound like your problem is EGR related, as the vehicle is cutting out randomly.

Another common problem with the WKs is with the ignition switch causing the engine to shut off...that could be something to look at (though I don't know if that is a problem with the commanders as well). However, without codes being thrown and any sort of pattern to stalling it will be tough to diagnose without actually having someone look at the vehicle and monitor it as the problem replicates.

vipper303 09-15-2013 06:16 PM

Re: another one stalling
 
Dr. lee, I appreciate your time very much. I did replace the egr today, and that also, did not work. There is no obvious reason why it is dying like it is. Although now, its not dying completely. Just droping rpms and resarting, unless its while driving, then a stop of anykind results in engine shutting off... I have thrown in the towel, realizing that I need real time data to see why it is acting the way that it is. If there is anything I should consider, or have the mechanic look for while he is looking at it would be very helpful. Again thank you so much for the time.

brentwoodkris 09-16-2013 11:07 AM

Re: another one stalling
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by vipper303 (Post 893891)
Dr. lee, I appreciate your time very much. I did replace the egr today, and that also, did not work. There is no obvious reason why it is dying like it is. Although now, its not dying completely. Just droping rpms and resarting, unless its while driving, then a stop of anykind results in engine shutting off... I have thrown in the towel, realizing that I need real time data to see why it is acting the way that it is. If there is anything I should consider, or have the mechanic look for while he is looking at it would be very helpful. Again thank you so much for the time.

I'd just replace the ignition switch. For $20 it's worth just replacing it as preventative maintenance. At least it is on the WK. Not sure about the XKs.

vipper303 09-18-2013 04:58 PM

Re: another one stalling
 
In appreciate all the help so far. It currently at a shop that I trust. So far the mechanic has checked it, and he has been unable to find any thing that he belives is the culprit. I will post back when I get it back on the road. thanks again to everyone.

swing4terps 09-18-2013 05:28 PM

Re: another one stalling
 
I was having similar problems with my 4.7. I replaced the TPS ($30 from Advance Auto) and have not stalled once since replacing. I would assume the Hemis have a TPS as well, but am not positive.

Frango100 09-19-2013 12:04 PM

Re: another one stalling
 
On the 4.7 we see this a lot due to a bad cam or crank sensor.

vipper303 09-19-2013 03:58 PM

Re: another one stalling
 
As of right now, the mechanic I have taken it to seems to think that it could be a crank sensor or throttle body. The crank sensor being cheaper, he is going ahead and trying that first. Have any of you heard about reprograming the computer for a new throttle body? I am trying to find more info on this, but the more info from more people I have the better understanding I have. Thanks so much for your all's help.

johngreen1234 09-20-2013 08:30 AM

Re: another one stalling
 
There is a long thread on the other Jeep Forum about this issue. The fault "appears" to be the upper engine wiring harness, which was apparently produced by a different vendor during the 07 model production, up to and including 08s built in August of 07. This wiring harness "may" have faulty splices, causing intermittent engine shutdowns due to unexpected spikes. There has never been a definitive code thrown, the engine just immediately stalls.

At least one owner replaced the harness, which seemed to work. However, fiddling with the engine harness seems to work also. Many owners have had success wrapping their harness junctions with foil as additional sheilding, which may be working simply because the splices are being pushed back together.

If it was me I would pull the car from the mechanic and test the harness on my own. With the engine idling I would gently tug around and see if I could get it to stall. I would NOT continue throwing parts and labor at this (other than possibly replacing the harness). Everything seems to work temporarily, but nobody can put their finger on what exactly is happening.

johngreen1234 09-20-2013 08:34 AM

Re: another one stalling
 
BTW, the most common precursor to this is using incorrect plugs. Not just Iridium, but Champion plugs bought from anywhere but the dealer. In the same Champion part #, one is silver-topped and the other is black-topped--and I can't remember which is the correct one. But to repeat, the correct Champion part number bought outside of a dealer is the wrong plug. But it doesn't always cause problems.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:59 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Copyright 2012 - JeepGarage.Org
The Jeep Grand Cherokee Owners Community