I'm currently running Toyo A/T 2's on my 2012 ram 3500. I've put about 12k miles on them since the beginning of the year. Being a 10ply, it's hard to compare to how the P metric would be, but compared to previous gen Toyo, they are a lot better on snow/ice, do well on loose dirty/mudd access roads(not muddin, just muddy from some thawing snow/rain), quieter too, and rain stability is pretty good, but again my dually with tools, etc weighs about 9klbs. I would consider them for personal vehicle, but I'm looking at Terra Grapplers(loved them on my last 1/2 ton) for the wife's ride...and she work's at Goodyear headquarters if that says what I think about most of Goodyear tires...I run Blizzaks in winter too, just not a big fan of GY. I considered the Coopers for my truck,good looking tread for what most people will use the Jeep for, but for the diesel dually, I went with the Toyo.